the centre:MK – A building worth listing in Milton Keynes?
the centre:MK (erstwhile Shopping Building) could shortly be in line for a grade II* listing which would prevent unsavoury (ok bias immediately present there) additions and changes to the central shopping precinct in the city. Some may say this all started the moment doors were put on the place; but its real degredation really begin with Midsummer Place, an extraordinarily ordinary building plonked next to the original 1970s Miesian building.
Unfortunately even the building’s management have described it in less than savoury terms, presumably because they want to be able to hack it about within an inch of its life to add more shops to the building and further the break-up of the orthogonal grid in Central Milton Keynes by closing the Secklow Gate flyover. This is the only flyover in Central Milton Keynes (and indeed most of MK, apart from the few junctions on the A5D and of course the M1) compared to other new-towns such as Peterborough and Runcorn that are full of high speed grade seperated junctions and flyovers.
Of course, much a-do about this listing has caught the interest of the Conservative leaning papers. I’ll bear my political clothes here but I am right leaning myself; but then I don’t have much time for politicians full stop but that’s another matter.
Between comments of ‘surrounded by concrete flyovers’ and ‘concrete eyesores’ – it doesn’t take much to work out what the papers think. They live seemingly in the romantic vision of England loved by Prince Charles and his somewhat disturbing Poundbury. Compared to most shopping centres in England, the centre:MK has is bursting with natural light, intricate but seemingly simple detail, elegant loading and unloading for deliveries (at first floor level hence the Secklow Gate flyover), the amazing steel-work and glass cladding and extensive interior planting that is by no means an after thought. Of course there was Queens Court at one time, but now that public space is being overturned into privatised space; squeeze the pounds out of every square foot is the mantra of business at the end of the day.
Maybe what they should be thinking of is building a counterweight. It’s no big secret the only reason the shopping building is the complete opposite end to the station of the 2km long city centre is because they had to guarantee that the project wouldn’t be cut down in size and trashed by short-sighted British incompetence. (And yes it is incompetence, short-term quick buck making for people who largely couldn’t give a toss.) And it worked as CMK now exists in its fully intended size but it needs an injection of life into the western end; so why not push the boat out architecturally and create a counterweight to the the centre:mk away from the heavily loaded eastern end?
There is plenty of room (because the designers thought about the future!) to do this if they had the vision but that doesn’t seem to have ever figured in the imagination.
You only have to see Midsummer Place (the extension built in the late 90s, opened in 2000 I think) is an alright looking thing but no work of art and certainly pretty run of the mill. The Shopping Building however is far from this uninspired building.
The book “The Story of the Original CMK” may be a little too rose tinted but it does deliver on 120 pages worth of excellent material the scale and sense of vision those guys had, if a bit naive – they created in part due to that what we see today. What we will create afterwards will likely as always be run by bean-counters but will be a watered down piss poor architectural tour-de-force in butchery.
Of The Times excelled themselves, take a look at this rather grotty picture of Central Milton Keynes:
It does look pretty rank from that photo, but there’s a small problem here given it is an article about The Shopping Building.
What’s the problem?
That picture DOES NOT CONTAIN any view of the shopping building!
I leave the final sentiment to Derek Walker, the shopping building should never have had bloody doors fitted on it. And the moment that happened, public space became private space…
- The Telegraph : Characterless Milton Keynes shopping zone at centre of culture clash
- The Times: English Heritage in move to save ‘concrete eyesores’ (you may note though I don’t disagree with them over Brum library but I never liked brutalist architecture)

Written by lilserenity on November 16th, 2009 with no comments.
Read more articles on otherSoftware and Uncategorized.























